Eastern Applied Research

  • Analyzer Sales
    • Coating Thickness >
      • Hitachi FT110A
      • Hitachi FT230
      • XStrata920
      • Hitachi FT160
      • Contact Gauges
    • Elemental Analyzers >
      • Hitachi EA6000VX
      • Hitachi EA1400
      • Hitachi EA1000AIII
      • Hitachi EA8000
      • Phthalates Tester
      • Bulk Analyzers
    • Handheld XRF Analyzers >
      • Hitachi XMet8000
      • Xmet Video Demos
      • Sample XRF Report
      • XRF Rental Info
    • Used XRF Analyzers >
      • Available Used XRF
    • Mexico XRF Sales
    • Spectrophotometers: UV, NIR, FL
  • Applications
    • Coating Thickness >
      • Common Coating Thickness
      • Ultra Thin Thickness
    • RoHS Testing
    • Alloy Analysis >
      • PMI: Alloy Testing
  • Service & Standards
    • Standards Laboratory >
      • New XRF Standards
      • XRF Standards Certification
      • Private Label Services
    • Instrument Services >
      • XRF Certification
      • Evaluation / Repair
      • Handheld XRF Services
      • Xray Radiation Safety Inspection
      • Protection Plans
    • Accreditations
  • Technology
    • Tech Blog
    • What is XRF?
    • XRF Benefits
    • XRF Resources
  • Contact / About
    • Contact
    • About
    • Join the Team
    • Testimonials
    • Sales Policy
  • Analyzer Sales
    • Coating Thickness >
      • Hitachi FT110A
      • Hitachi FT230
      • XStrata920
      • Hitachi FT160
      • Contact Gauges
    • Elemental Analyzers >
      • Hitachi EA6000VX
      • Hitachi EA1400
      • Hitachi EA1000AIII
      • Hitachi EA8000
      • Phthalates Tester
      • Bulk Analyzers
    • Handheld XRF Analyzers >
      • Hitachi XMet8000
      • Xmet Video Demos
      • Sample XRF Report
      • XRF Rental Info
    • Used XRF Analyzers >
      • Available Used XRF
    • Mexico XRF Sales
    • Spectrophotometers: UV, NIR, FL
  • Applications
    • Coating Thickness >
      • Common Coating Thickness
      • Ultra Thin Thickness
    • RoHS Testing
    • Alloy Analysis >
      • PMI: Alloy Testing
  • Service & Standards
    • Standards Laboratory >
      • New XRF Standards
      • XRF Standards Certification
      • Private Label Services
    • Instrument Services >
      • XRF Certification
      • Evaluation / Repair
      • Handheld XRF Services
      • Xray Radiation Safety Inspection
      • Protection Plans
    • Accreditations
  • Technology
    • Tech Blog
    • What is XRF?
    • XRF Benefits
    • XRF Resources
  • Contact / About
    • Contact
    • About
    • Join the Team
    • Testimonials
    • Sales Policy

X-ray Fluorescence: Energy Dispersive v. Wavelength Dispersive

7/26/2012

0 Comments

 
As organizations research analytical equipment to solve particular material analysis needs, they will contact Eastern Applied Research regarding x-ray fluorescence technology. From time to time, contacts will ask about two difference styles of x-ray technologies - Wavelength Dispersive (WD-XRF) and Energy Dispersive (ED-XRF).
As specialists in ED-XRF analyzers, Eastern Applied has seen improvements in the technology that have resulted in expanded application fields and make it a consideration for applications that used to be solved by WD-XRF. This article provides a brief comparison of the two technologies. Contact Eastern Applied to discuss further and see if ED-XRF is a fit for your applications.

Both technologies are based around the principle of using an x-ray source to excite a sample, a detection system to collect fluoresced x-rays, and a software program to process the measurement data. The difference in a wavelength system is that a crystal between the tubes diffracts x-rays of a specific wavelength into the detector tube. This added step (and components) results in varying performance capabilities and costs between the technologies. 

Two main differences that affect performance: 

Energy Resolution - depending on the instrument specifics, WD-XRF analyzers will provide resolutions of 5eV to 20eV while ED-XRF systems typically offer a range of 120eV to 220eV. The lower resolutions of WD-XRF will reduce spectral overlaps and provide more efficient characterization of complex samples. While this difference may benefit wavelength technology for a specific element of interest or application, the optical components required to achieve those resolutions result in a more expensive system - both in the initial cost of acquisition and over the course of its lifespan. Advancements in ED-XRF detection systems have improved those resolutions greatly and we have seen an increased range of applications solved by ED-XRF due, in part, to those advancements. 

Spectral Acquisition - this is a factor that limits wavelength dispersive technology as a spectrum is either made in a point-by-point fashion (very time consuming) or has additional detectors (very costly approach). Energy dispersive, on the other hand, will acquire an entire spectrum almost simultaneously. While a user may see a slight reduction in accuracy for one element, the range of elements seen are achieved in a faster, more efficient, approach and result in a broader range of material analysis capabilities.

At Eastern Applied Research, we specialize in the energy dispersive x-ray fluorescence technology. We have been part of ED-XRF's evolution over the last twenty years and appreciate the benefits it offers over wavelength, benefits of ED-XRF include: 
  • lower cost of acquisition
  • broader, more diverse, analytical scope
  • lower cost of maintenance
  • greater reliability due to less complicated design
  • less electrical power consumption

In addition to those benefits, energy dispersive x-ray fluorescence has seen great improvements over recent years, including the addition of poly-capillary optics (seen in the micro-XRF Hitachi FT-150) and extremely versatile systems like the Hitachi EA6000VX.

If you are considering x-ray fluorescence and would like to learn more about ED-XRF options or the difference between technologies, we encourage you to request a conversation from an Eastern Applied Research XRF specialist.
0 Comments

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    Archives

    June 2022
    April 2022
    January 2022
    December 2021
    July 2019
    May 2018
    April 2018
    February 2018
    July 2017
    May 2017
    January 2017
    August 2016
    February 2016
    July 2015
    June 2015
    September 2013
    March 2013
    November 2012
    July 2012
    December 2011
    November 2011
    July 2011
    May 2011
    April 2011

    RSS Feed

    Suscribe to our email newsletter

Suscribe

More news & Info

Blog
Contact Us
About Us
Accreditation
Proudly powered by Weebly